Unfair Demotion will be Punished by CCMA

lvan lsraelstam

Employers fairly frequently demote employees. This could be for any of many legitimate and illegitimate reasons including:

• The boss dislikes the employee
• The employee has broken a rule
• The employee’s work performance is unsatisfactory
• The boss wants to create a vacancy for somebody else
• Things have gone wrong and the boss needs a scapegoat
• The employer cannot afford to pay the employee’s salary
• The employee is no longer able to carry out his/her job due to illness/injury

Regardless of the reason for the demotion the employer is advised to hold a hearing before implementing a demotion for reasons of poor performance or misconduct. While the Labour Relations Act (LRA) does not specifically require a hearing in such cases it is important to hold a hearing because:

• The spirit of the LRA requires that it is unfair to punish an employee without giving him/her a chance to defend the case
• Failure to hold the hearing will make it difficult to prove, on record, that the employee was guilty and that the reason for the demotion was fair.

What constitutes a demotion is not always straightforward. In different circumstances alleged demotions can occur in numerous ways including:

• The employer gives the employee a letter stating that he/she has been demoted
• The employee’s pay and/or responsibilities are reduced
• The employee’s subordinates are taken away
• The employee is required to report to someone who used to report to him/her.
• An employee acting temporarily in one position gets transferred back to his/her old position

Regardless of the circumstances employers are advised to take the law into account before doing anything that could potentially resemble demotion. This is because, should the CCMA or bargaining council find the demotion to be unfair the arbitrator has the right to:

• Reinstate the employee into the position from which he/she was demoted
• Award the employee compensation
• Apply any other corrective measure that he/she deems to be appropriate.

For example, in the case of Mavimbela vs Sterikleen (Pty) Ltd (2006, 11 BALR 1128) the employee had been a cleaner. He was later asked to carry out supervisory duties but, after failing to carry out these duties properly, he was relegated to being a cleaner. The employer said that the employee had never been promoted but rather had been asked to carry out limited supervisory duties in return for receiving an allowance. The removal of the allowance and of the supervisory duties as a result of poor performance was not unfair.

However, the arbitrator found that the employer had failed to prove that the employee had in fact performed poorly. He found therefore that the employer had acted unfairly and ordered the employer to pay the employee compensation equal to eight months’ of the extra supervisory ‘bonus” granted when he was given the supervisory duties.

In Plaatjies vs RK Agencies (2005, 1 BALR 77) the employer offered the employee an alternative post at a lower salary due to the fact that the employer had lost a major contract. While the arbitrator accepted this as a valid reason the demotion was still unfair because the employer had failed to consult with the employee before making the offer. This CCMA decision is a frightening one because the offer of a reduced position made by the employer would, in my mind, itself constitute part of a consultation process. That is, the employer was not accused of implementing the demotion but merely of offering the employee a reduced position.

In Sass vs African Life Assurance (2005, 6 BALR 682) the employer demoted the employee for failing to make sufficient sales. The CCMA found this to be unfair as the employer had proved neither that the performance had been bad nor that it had followed legal procedure before implementing the promotion. The employer was ordered to reinstate the employee in the higher position.

In view of the above case decisions employers should never implement demotion before obtaining expert labour law advice as to:

• Whether the demotion is merited
• The procedure to be followed in implementing a fair demotion

lvan lsraelstam is the Chief Executive of Labour Law Management Consulting. He may be contacted on 082 852 2973 or on e-mail address: [email protected].

Our appreciation to Ivan and The Star newspaper for permission to publish this article.

You may also be interested in reading some of the following articles.

1 Working Hours and Overtime 2 CALCULATION OF EMPLOYEE’S REMUNERATION IN TERMS 3 SECTORAL DETERMINATION 9: WHOLESALE AND RETAIL SECTOR 4 Unpaid leave vs. Deduction from salaries 5 Unilateral Changes 6 Unilateral changes to terms and conditions of employment 7 Types of Leave: Explanatory notes 8 Two holidays or one? 9 Time: is it the enemy? 10 Those 24-Hour Notices 11 The vital importance of keeping records 12 The Saga of the Threshold Earnings and the BCEA 13 The Regulation of Working Time. 14 The reasonable decision maker test 15 The payment of bonuses 16 THE PAYMENT OF BONUSES – PART 2. 17 The Earnings Threshold. 18 The Basic Conditions of Employment Act: 19 Domestic Workers 20 Sectoral Determination 13: Farm Workers 21 Resignations – what are the employers rights? 22 Religious Holidays 23 Regulations leave room for many interpretations 24 Public Holidays – The Final Episode 25 Public Holidays 26 PUBLIC HOLIDAYS: USEFUL INFORMATION 27 PUBLIC HOLIDAYS THAT FALLS ON SUNDAYS 28 WRITTEN PARTICULARS 29 SECTORAL DETERMINATION SEVEN: DOMESTIC WORKER SECTOR 30 Private Security 31 NOTICE OF CANCELLATION OF REGISTRATION OF TRADE UNIONS AND EMPLOYERS’ ORGANISATIONS 32 NOTICE 1367 OF 1998 33 BASIC CONDITIONS OF EMPLOYMENT ACT, 1997 34 Minimum Wages 35 Maternity leave can’t be reduced by a contract 36 Maternity leave and Annual leave. 37 TYPES OF LEAVE. (Part 2) 38 Types of Leave. 39 Leave 40 Everything you need to know about leave 41 It’s crucial to get the training right first time 42 IT’S BONUS TIME AGAIN – ALMOST!! 43 I have resigned and have 25 days leave due to me. Can I take this leave during my notice period ? I have told my employer I want to take my leave in my period of notice but he refuses. 44 Hours of Work and Overtime: 45 Family Responsibility leave 46 Employees rights. 47 Employees have lion’s share of legal rights 48 EMPLOYEE RIGHTS. 49 Deductionsns from remuneration. 50 Deductions from remuneration. 51 Contract Cleaning Sector 52 SECTORAL DETERMINATION: HOSPITALITY SECTOR 53 Click here to download Sectoral determination 6: 54 Click here to download Sectoral Determination 1: Contract cleaning sector (30 pages) 55 Can I exchange may annual leave for cash? 56 Calculation of accrual of leave – 1,25 days per month or 1,5 days per month. 57 Calculation of accrual of annual leave – 1 hour for every 17 hours worked . 58 BONUSES RE-VISITED 59 THE PAYMENT OF BONUSES: RE-VISITED 60 Basic conditions of employment 61 Annual leave during a period of notice. 62 Annual leave and shutdown. 63 Annual Leave – to pay or not to pay – that is the question 64 Annual leave – Must it be paid? Must it be taken ? Or is it forfeited? 65 Summary of the ACT (BCEA) in terms of Section 30 66 Abuse of sick leave, unauthorised absenteeism, abscondment and desertion 67 ANNUAL LEAVE 68 BCEA Section 69 Annual Leave Shutdown 2 70 Anuual Leave 71 Leave Paid 72 Bonuses 73 Leave Section